How are the nominees decided?
Nominees for The Music Victoria Awards are chosen via an extensive selection process.
An Awards committee from Music Victoria select a panel of 30+ industry judges from radio, music blogs, print media, record stores, festivals and more to submit a long list of up to 10 nominations in each category. These lists are then collated into a large voting survey and it is distributed again to judges to vote.
If a judge has a conflict of interest with one of the nominations they will raise this conflict with the Awards committee and the panel will use their discretion to make a decision.
The top five from these results are then selected as the nominees for public vote. Of course, nominations will always be competitive and in the event of a tie, the Awards committee may do a countback, refer to the criteria and will ultimately have the final decision.
- At least 50% of the act has been living in Victoria for the last two years, or uses Melbourne as a home base.
- Released an album, multiple singles or EP (category dependent) between 1 September 2018 and 31 August 2019
- Victorian venues or festival
Gender and Diversity Quotas for long lists
Panel judges must endeavour to create a longlist of nominees achieving 40:40:20 gender diversity (in line with Music Victoria and the Victorian Government's gender diversity targets - that is, no less than 40% of women, or 40% men, with 20% unallocated).
Consideration must also be given to cultural diversity, with best attempts made to include cultural diversity in longlist selections.
What is ‘Victorian’?
The majority of the band (at least 50%) producing the music must be current permanent residents of Victoria (and have lived in Victoria for at least the last two years). The band’s / artist’s music must be available for sale in Victoria and the band / artist must perform in Victoria regularly.
If the act is performing under a solo artist name, the 50% rule does not apply to members of their backing band. The lead performer must reside in Victoria (and have done so for at least two years) to be eligible.
If an artist has moved away recently, they are eligible as long as they were living in Victoria for 2 years immediately prior to and during the making of their submitted music/live activity.
What is ‘Best’?
Depending on the category and in the opinion of the judges, the nominee who shows the most excellence in contemporary music in the period between 1 September 2018 and 31 August 2019. Factors considered include but are not limited to - connection with audience; volume and quality of shows; live appeal; innovation and Victorian spirit.
What's an ‘Album’?
As a guide but not a definition - an album would be generally accepted to have at least nine tracks, or 33 minutes in length, and a minimum requirement that a track includes at least 20 seconds of music. We understand that artists define whether their release is an album or ep, and some genres are more likely to have short songs and therefore; albums that fall short of 33 minutes in length.
Live albums and cover albums are also eligible.
Best 'Act' awards
An act may include a solo artist that performs under their own name or a pseudonym, or it may be a band. A band is comprised of two or more people - a group of musicians who play music together both on stage and in the studio and are known as a collective. We have "Best Album" vs "Best Act" awards as we recognise that not all genres and communities are album-focused, and the title and accompanying criteria for each category is determined in consultation with the chair of the panel.
'Best Act' recognises nominees who show the most excellence in contemporary music singles, eps, albums, live performance and music community activated and/or released in the period between 1 September 2018 and 31 August 2019.
What's a 'Song'?
A song is a short musical composition of words and music. Instrumental songs are also eligible to be nominated.
What's a 'Band'?
A band is comprised of two or more people - a group of musicians who play music together both on stage and in the studio as a collective under a band name.
Best Solo Artist
‘Best Solo Artist’ may include an artist that performs under their own name or a pseudonym. This category does not include lead singers of bands unless they're being nominated for a separate and current solo career (i.e. they release music and play shows under their own name or solo pseudonym). If you are performing under a solo artist name, you must reside in Victoria to be eligible (residency of backing band is not considered).
Best Male and Female Musician
‘Best Male and Female Musician’ may include an artist that performs as part of a band or as a solo artist, and who makes an extraordinary contribution to that act.
Best Breakthrough Act
'Best Breakthrough Act' (previously known as Best Emerging Act) may include an artist who has released multiple singles, an EP or debut album, but cannot include an artist who has released more than one album. Artists cannot be nominated twice for 'Best Breakthrough Act' (or Best Emerging Act as it was previously known). Factors considered include but are not limited to - connection with audience and live appeal; quality and size of shows; quality of releases; current buzz; innovation; and Victorian spirit.
Archie Roach Foundation Award for Emerging Talent
“Once again on behalf of the Foundation I am proud to have this award presented to the next up and coming First Nations artist to support them and their music.” - Archie Roach.
What is ‘Emerging’?
‘Emerging’ describes an act, (solo or group) in the formative stages of their musical career, experiencing demonstrated artistic achievement and growing public recognition.
Factors considered include but are not limited to –
*outstanding artistic quality reflected in single, EP or album releases
*chart success (eg: community radio, ARIA, Spotify)
*broadcast, digital and social media activity (current buzz)
*audience development and live appeal (quality and size of shows)
* Victorian spirit
Acts must have released an EP, album or multiple singles in the period between 1 September 2018 and 31 August 2019.
Acts can be nominated multiple times over the years for this award, but cannot be re-nominated if they have previously won.
Best Intercultural Act (previously Best Global Act)
We define Intercultural music as music that is the result of mutually respectful cultural dialogue and expression communicated in musical forms, such as instrumentation, arrangement, participation, and/or language.
This could include examples such as:
- A solo artist from Africa playing a kora alone on stage/release, who has been based in Victoria for at least 2 years.
- A band comprised of all Greek musicians playing Greek Rembetiko music, with at least 50% of its members having been based in Victoria for at least 2 years.
- A band comprised of all Anglo-Australian members playing traditional instruments and musical style of another culture, with at least 50% of its members having been based in Victoria for at least 2 years.
- A band playing music from a mix of cultures in a style not represented in the available genre categories, with at least 50% of its members having been based in Victoria for at least 2 years.
"Intercultural describes communities in which there is a deep understanding and respect for all cultures. Intercultural communication focuses on the mutual exchange of ideas and cultural norms and the development of deep relationships. In an intercultural society, no one is left unchanged because everyone learns from one another and grows together."
Source: The Spring Institute.
Best Live Act
Best Live Act can be a band or solo artist. Said act must be known for their exceptional live show and must have performed multiple live shows in Victoria between 1 September 2018 to 31 August 2019 to be eligible.
Best Regional and Outer Suburban Act
'‘Best Regional and Outer Suburban Act’ may include a solo artist or band that has at least 50% of its members residing outside of the Melbourne metro area (including outer suburbs) that by reason of geographical location may face barriers in their music pursuits which have been overcome.
What is 'Regional and Outer Suburban'?
We class 'Regional and Outer Suburban' as an act residing or venue located outside of the Melbourne metro area (including outer suburbs based more than 15 kilometres from Melbourne GPO) that by reason of geographical location may face barriers in their music pursuits which have been overcome. At least half of the group will live outside the Melbourne metropolitan area.
A music festival is an organized event, lasting one or more days, featuring performances by various musicians, singers, and groups. Factors considered when nominating include but are not limited to - commitment to live music & the Victorian music community, volume and quality of live music element; quality of sound system; quality of overall experience; quality of treatment of musicians, booking that fosters diversity and inclusivity, efforts to reduce the environmental impact of the event; and efforts by the promoter to provide a safe and inclusive environment for musicians, patrons and staff. Any festival may be nominated in a long list by a judge, however only one festival per site can ultimately be nominated for public vote for each promoter/site.
Best Venue Categories
Any venue that hosts contemporary live music may be nominated in a long list by a judge. Factors considered when nominating include but are not limited to - commitment to live music & the local music community, volume and quality of shows; quality of sound system; quality of overall experience; quality of treatment of musicians, booking that fosters diversity and inclusivity, efforts to reduce the environmental impact of the venue; and efforts by the venue to provide a safe and inclusive environment for musicians, patrons and staff.
There are four Best Venue awards:
- Best Venue (under 500 cap)
- Best Venue (over 500 cap)
- Best Regional and Outer Suburban Venue (under 50 gigs per year)
- Best Regional and Outer Suburban Venue (over 50 gigs per year)